Given how sluggish the controls are, that would be nauseating.
I also think I’m gonna have to play this the same way I played gta5. Mostly controller, but during gun fights, drop controller in lap and use kb+m. The first gun fight in the game was horrid on the controller.
Gun fight is complete and utter shit in RDR2. It doesn’t matter what you use. With the controller, you’ll probably be better off since the game forces you to auto aim anyway.
For me it was literally snapping to the enemies. In the first mission where I was killing the wolves, it was mostly auto aim combat. Maybe it works differently on console than on the PC version.
It doesn’t snap to targets Mili, you must have some option still on or it is your imagination. Once you get good at shooting in the game the gunplay is very good. The hit boxes are spot on, headshots are bloody and satisfying often giving a slow mo cam to enjoy your work. Many times when surrounded I’d shoot the legs out of half the enemies and mow the rest down. Upgrade your weapons or kill notable characters and take theirs and you’ll enjoy it more.